Thomas GRUND (University College Dublin) – “Public Denunciation and the Limits of Scandal”
June 20, 12:00 pm - 1:15 pm
The Sociology Seminar: Thursdays
Time: 12:00 pm – 1:15 pm
Date: 20th of June 2019
Place: Room 3105, ENSAE.
Thomas GRUND (University College Dublin) – “Public Denunciation and the Limits of Scandal“
Abstract : Scandals around deviant affairs, such as corruption of economic or political elites, are expected to reveal truths. In this study, we argue that public inquiries into scandals uncover only a limited amount of knowledge because of the endogenous network dynamics of the underlying denunciation process. This article analyzes the testimonies given during a Canadian Royal Commission, referred to as the Gomery Commission, which unfolded throughout 2004-2005 and inquired into the inner workings of a corruption scandal within the federal government of Canada. Analyses are based on original data of relational denunciation events that emerged from the public testimonies of 172 witnesses. Multilevel discrete-time event history analyses are applied to demonstrate the temporal and relational embeddedment of denunciation. Witnesses in the Commission’s proceedings tend to reciprocate denunciations, denounce others who have been previously denounced, and punish those who reveal too much information. We conclude that the dynamics of denunciation maintain secrecy more effectively and consistently than they produce knowledge about deviant activities.
Jeanne GANAULT, Céline GOFFETTE, Sander WAGNER (Laboratoire de sociologie quantitative – CREST)